Does mindset affect wealth?
It’s the question that makes the abundance mindset something worth fighting for, or just another woo-woo concept to gloss over, smile at, and lose interest in.
Can a mindset shift actually change your bank account? Or is the whole idea of feeling abundant just that — a feeling?
It turns out that mindset does impact wealth in some pretty profound ways. Research published in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences (PNAS) shows that a scarcity mindset triggers biological changes in the brain. As a result of these changes, we devote precious mental processing power to the resource we feel we lack at the expense of working memory and goal-directed decision-making.
You might have goals, and you probably know they’re important, but the will, confidence, and motivation to take risks or implement a series of steps and stick with them isn’t there.
Here’s the good news: it’s not your fault. It’s just your brain operating in survival mode and not knowing how to switch that mode off. Realizing what’s happening is the first step to flipping that switch, shifting your mental process from survival mode — tunnel vision, habitual thinking, and limited cognitive bandwidth — to abundance mode — clarity on intertemporal trade-offs, goal-directed thinking, and more cognitive bandwidth.
Or, another way to think of it: you get your brain back.
What researchers have learned about scarcity mindset
Experiencing a lack of resources creates a scarcity mindset.
This mindset, according to the researchers who published the 2019 PNAS study, is characterized by “increasing attention toward the scarce resource itself, but at the cost of attention for unrelated aspects.” You’re focusing on the problem at the expense of the solution.
The authors of the 2013 book, Scarcity: Why Having Too Little Means So Much, came to a similar conclusion. Behavioral economist Sendhil Mullainathan and cognitive psychologist Eldar Shafir call it the bandwidth tax. The mind is constantly processing the resource crisis in the background, leaving less processing power for other things.
So, what’s actually happening in the brain when you think this way? How does it impact our cognitive ability (spoiler alert: it causes an IQ drop)? And what about stress, confidence, and just how demoralizing the emotional impact of scarcity really is? Let’s take a look.
The cognitive impact
The researchers who published the PNAS study looked at the brain scans of participants when they had a scarcity mindset vs. an abundance mindset. They found two distinct changes in the brain with the scarcity mindset:
- There’s increased activity in the orbitofrontal cortex (OFC), a brain region that plays a role in the valuation process.
This explains the greater mental focus on the scarce resource, such as money, food, or time. When hungry, time-poor, or financially poor, the drive state is high, so any stimuli that can reduce that drive earn an elevated amount of attention.
- There’s a decrease in activity in the dorsolateral prefrontal cortex (dlPFC), an area known for its role in goal-directed decision-making.
This area is involved in several really important cognitive processes that relate to goal-directed behavior, including working memory and executive control.
With restricted working memory, your brain can’t simultaneously process as many variables as it normally could. You basically default to assessing fewer decision variables than you would if you had an abundant mindset. This is unconscious, so you don’t even realize you’re doing it.
With diminished executive control, you aren’t as capable of steering your behavior toward long-range objectives. For example, you might know that spending an hour a day working through a coding course would help you upskill and eventually earn more, but when self-regulation, maintaining attention, and deliberate planning are harder to do, you’re less likely to follow through. It’s just more of an uphill battle.
With this cognitive drop, it’s harder to make decisions that truly reflect your goals and what’s genuinely best for you and your future.
As Mullainathan and Shahir explain, you’re vulnerable to errors, emotional volatility, and making impulsive decisions that help now, but will hurt later. In their research, they also found an average IQ drop of 13 to 14 points. It’s as if you lost an entire night of restorative sleep, wake up, and have to figure out how to dig yourself out of a crisis.
How can you be creative, plan strategically, or take calculated risks when, frankly, you’re not operating with a full deck?
The emotional impact
According to the PNAS study (that looked at how a scarcity mindset alters neural processing), participants who were experiencing scarcity also reported feeling less confident and more stressed.
If you’re less confident and more stressed, you’re less creative, making it harder to find the pathway out of your current situation.
Being in a scarcity mindset doesn’t mean you don’t intellectually understand the value of saving or investing. You probably know the importance better than anyone. But it’s really hard to make the decisions or take the actions that build wealth. Because it’s stressful. Because there’s too much risk. Because you have to figure out how to pay this month’s electricity bill before you can even think about your retirement savings.
But here’s the good news: shifting to an abundance mindset can turn all these cognitive and emotional challenges around.
A study published in the Journal of Workplace Behavioral Health that looked at the impact of a scarcity vs. an abundance mindset on employees found that an abundance mindset “encourages employees to reframe challenges as opportunities.” By reducing fears related to failure and resource scarcity, an abundance mentality nurtures creative problem-solving and innovation. It also increases motivation.
Adopting an abundance mindset is definitely worth it. But it’s difficult to do if you’re not conscious of the problem and intentionally working to shift from scarcity mode to abundance. It’s just too easy to get trapped in a scarcity mentality because the limiting effects on your brain, your cognitive capabilities, and your emotional state are all happening in the background.
Why it’s easy to get trapped in a scarcity mindset
Imagine you’re walking through the desert. It’s hot; you’ve been wandering for almost two days. You need water, desperately. All you can think about is getting a drink. Just one gulp, and you’ll be okay.
Up ahead, you notice what looks like a small plastic bottle of water lying in the sand. You run to it, drop to your knees, screw off the top, and drink. Your thirst is satiated, and you’re going to survive, for now. This is good news.
But what you missed by stopping here is the well up ahead, just another mile and over a small hill. On the other side of this hill, the terrain changes. It shifts from desert and brush to green valleys, lush forests, and hills teeming with resources that you can access to make your life better. If you reached it, you could tap into a natural spring that offers endless water. You could walk over to that well at any point if you knew it was there.
However, just then, a person, well-dressed, approaches. They smile and offer you a deal: they’ll give you another bottle of water if you work for them. Just half the day each day. And they’re willing to pay. You’ll have some money in your pocket to buy more bottles of water, as well as food, and maybe even rent one of the huts they point to where the other workers live. You’ll still have time for yourself. You’ll still have a life of your own.
You’re tired, and you don’t see a better option, so you agree.
The problem is that, because you’re busy working so you can buy the things you want and need in your newfound desert town, you don’t bother going further, over the dunes, to where the well is. Why would you? You might not make it back to your relative safety. Someone else might take your place if you leave. Why give up good enough if you don’t have to?
What would you do if you were in this situation? You don’t know the well exists. You don’t know this person is drawing from it to get the water they’re selling you. And you don’t know that you can draw from that well, too.
Before, you were desperate and dying of thirst. Now you’ll have food, water, and maybe even a home. Would you really venture into the unknown, take risks, and give up a sense of security if you didn’t have to?
How can you escape a scarcity mindset and start living with abundance?
Ultimately, when you’re worried about lack, you’re robbed of the one thing that would help you get out of the scarcity situation in the first place: agency. The ability to act according to one’s will. Instead, there’s an unconscious, habitual mental loop that keeps you locked in place — hyper-focused on dealing with immediate need, so you literally can’t process long-term goals, let alone act on them.
Breaking those habitual thinking patterns takes work, as you have to convince your brain that you’re living in abundance. That’s how you can avoid the neural mechanisms that might be stopping you from thriving or reaching your goals.
The practice of abundance is a wide world, with tons of techniques and practices you can choose to use, but first, start simple. Here are three tips to help you start shifting today:
- Feel gratitude: Research shows that gratitude boosts brain activity and improves psychological well-being. You can write down three things you’re grateful for each day, or simply say them to yourself. Best times to program your mind with gratitude: right when you wake up or right before bed.
- Treat yourself: You don’t have to sacrifice what you may perceive as a limited resource, whether it’s time, money, or something else. The goal here is to start getting used to feeling good with something that’s positive, even if it’s small. That might mean setting aside 20 minutes for a walk, an online yoga session, a guided meditation, or a hot bath. Make yourself a nutritious meal, even if it takes a little more time. Maybe it’s listening to an audiobook or podcast you like, drawing while listening to your favorite playlist, or reading a book. Do something for yourself every day.
- Make time for building wealth: Set a time slot — it can be an hour on Sunday afternoon, or 30 minutes on Monday morning — for planning and problem-solving. You don’t have to figure out all your problems in one day. The idea is to help your mind start reorienting around solutions and opportunities rather than scarcity, limits, and lack. Make a list of ideas, free-write, talk to a friend, or just play around with ideas in your mind.
Every step you take to get yourself out of the desert and over that hill is one step closer to abundance — and the will to access it.
Frequently asked questions
What is a scarcity mindset?
A scarcity mindset is a perceived lack of a valuable resource that captures your attention. We often associate it with being poor, but you can have a modest income and live abundantly. At the same time, you can have a large income and still feel like you don’t have enough.
A scarcity mentality can also be rooted in feeling like you don’t have enough time.
Whatever the resource, scarcity becomes a lived condition that, as educational psychology researcher Dr. Mohammed Looti explains, “alters the fundamental architecture of human cognition.”
What does science say about an abundance mindset and work?
Researchers have found that an abundance mindset is associated with less stress, greater resilience, and higher motivation. People are more innovative, creative, open-minded, and productive.
How does financial scarcity impact cognitive performance?
Researchers have found that there’s less cognitive power for other things because the brain involuntarily gives heightened attention to the source of lack.
At the same time, people can be more savvy because they’ve experienced scarcity in the past or are dealing with it now. A meta-analysis published in the Journal of Economic Psychology mentions several studies showing that people experiencing scarcity are often more careful about how they spend their money.
